Discover Top 8 Fish Markets In Nantucket

October 30, 2023

Nantucket, an island known for its natural beauty and maritime charm, offers a seafood experience like no other. With its rich seafaring history and bountiful waters, the nantucket fish markets are some of the finest in the Northeast.

From succulent lobster to freshly caught oysters, the nantucket seafood markets are a testament to the island’s dedication to providing residents and visitors with the highest quality, locally sourced seafood. In this article, we will take you on a gastronomic journey to explore the top seven quality seafood markets on Nantucket, where you can indulge in the island’s maritime traditions and savor the flavors of the sea.

Our Favorite Nantucket Fish Markets

1. Nantucket Seafoods

Address: 56 Old South Rd
City/State: Nantucket, Massachusetts

Nantucket Seafoods, perched on the picturesque Nantucket Island, is a seafood lover’s paradise. Nestled at 56 Old South Road, this charming fresh fish market is where island residents and visitors come for the best seafood experience on Nantucket. With a keen focus on providing the freshest catches from the surrounding waters, Nantucket Seafoods excels in delivering a delightful array of seafood treasures. Whether you’re seeking succulent lobsters, plump Nantucket Bay scallops, or a variety of gourmet items, this market has it all.

Their commitment to quality is unmatched, making them a go-to source for both retail and wholesale customers. Moreover, the option for delivery adds to the convenience and ensures that their best seafood can grace your table even if you’re not on the island. Nantucket Seafoods embodies the island’s dedication to providing locals and tourists with the finest seafood selections, making it a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts in Nantucket.

2. Nantucket Meat & Fish Market

Address: 21 Old South Rd
City/State: Nantucket, Massachusetts

Nantucket Meat & Fish Market is a true gem on the island, where their commitment to quality and personalized service shines. As a family-owned and operated business, they prioritize ensuring that every customer has the best possible experience. Whether you’re seeking the freshest seafood, prime cuts of meat, delectably prepared foods, or gourmet groceries, this market has it all.

What sets Nantucket Meat & Fish Market apart is their dedication to serving the island with a smile. The friendly and knowledgeable staff are always eager to assist you in finding what you need, answering your questions, and even accommodating special orders. It’s a one-stop destination for all your culinary desires, with an array of offerings, including a bagel bakery, cafe, sushi, and, of course, best seafood.

For residents and visitors alike, Nantucket Meat & Fish Market is a cornerstone of the island’s culinary scene, a place where you can count on quality, variety, and exceptional service.

3. Sayle’s Seafood

Address: 99 Washington St. Extension
City/State: Nantucket, Massachusetts

Sayle’s Seafood on Nantucket is the island’s best-kept seafood secret. It’s a true fish market with the added convenience of prepared food. Whether you’re looking to enjoy a meal right away or take home a seafood feast, Sayle’s has you covered. Their portions are generous, so sharing is often the best strategy. From the freshest fluke and striped bass to Atlantic salmon and Pacific king salmon, their selection of fresh fish is impressive.

You can also find seasonal catches like bluefish and black sea bass. When it comes to shellfish, they offer Nantucket Bay scallops, Atlantic Sea scallops, steamers, and more. The live lobster selection includes various sizes to suit your preference. Sayle’s even carries prepared foods like crab cakes, clambakes, and clam chowder, making it a one-stop shop for a delectable seafood experience.

Sayle’s Seafood is Nantucket’s hidden gem for seafood lovers, providing the island with the finest and freshest catches of the sea.

4. Souza’s Seafood

Address: 23 Trotters Ln
City/State: Nantucket, Massachusetts

Souza’s Seafood, a delightful seafood market and restaurant on the picturesque island of Nantucket, offers a seafood selection that’s truly exceptional. From the moment you enter, the tantalizing aroma of the sea envelops you, and you know you’re in for a treat.

The extensive menu is a testament to Souza’s dedication to serving the freshest and most delicious seafood available. Start your culinary journey with the calamari, a mouthwatering appetizer that sets the stage for the feast to come. Then, indulge in their fresh catch, which showcases the very best of Nantucket’s marine treasures.

While Souza’s Seafood isn’t the cheapest option on the island, the quality of the seafood and the dining experience are well worth it. The establishment is easily accessible with convenient parking and even offers bike racks for eco-conscious diners. So, if you’re seeking an exquisite seafood dining experience that captures the essence of Nantucket, look no further than Souza’s Seafood. It’s a culinary adventure you won’t soon forget.

5. Glidden’s Island Seafood

Address: 115 Pleasant St
City/State: Nantucket, Massachusetts

Glidden’s Island Seafood has stood as a Nantucket institution since 1898, a testament to its enduring commitment to providing the island’s finest seafood. Nestled in the heart of Nantucket, this quality seafood market has been serving both locals and visitors with the freshest catch of the day. The century-old tradition of quality and excellence is palpable from the moment you step inside.

With its doors open year-round, Glidden’s has become a staple for those who crave the taste of the sea. Whether you’re in search of succulent fish, delectable meats, or even everyday groceries, this seafood market has you covered. The air is perpetually infused with the briny scent of fresh fish, an olfactory testament to the quality within.

Glidden’s Island Seafood is more than a market; it’s a time-honored institution, a culinary destination where you can experience the authentic flavors of Nantucket’s maritime heritage. Don’t miss the chance to savor the island’s finest at this historic establishment.

6. 167 Raw Nantucket

Address: 167 Hummock Pond Rd
City/State: Nantucket, Massachusetts

167 Raw Nantucket is an island gem, an establishment that encapsulates the essence of Nantucket’s seafood culture. Founded in 1978 as East Coast Provisions & Seafood Co. by Bill Sandole, this iconic fish market is now an integral part of the 167Raw family. Located at 167 Hummock Pond Rd, this fish market has evolved over the years into a culinary hub. While seafood is its heart and soul, it offers much more.

From prime meats to a unique wine and beer selection, fine cheeses, and various gourmet items, 167 Raw Nantucket has expanded its offerings without losing sight of its seafood origins. Open for nine months of the year, it remains a coveted destination for both islanders and visitors. Here, you can find not only the freshest catch of the day but also an array of culinary delights to complement your seafood dishes. The commitment to quality and the celebration of Nantucket’s maritime traditions are what make 167 Raw Nantucket a standout seafood market on the island.

7. Millie’s Market-Nantucket

Address: 324 Madaket Rd
City/State: Nantucket, Massachusetts

Millie’s Market-Nantucket, a beloved seafood market on the island, beautifully embodies the spirit of Nantucket and its maritime heritage. Named after the legendary ‘Madaket Millie’ Jewett, whose indomitable spirit and love for the island left an indelible mark, this market pays homage to her legacy by offering more than just a place to purchase seafood.

Millie’s stands as a testament to the island’s commitment to preserving its unique traditions. Whether you’re a long-time local or a first-time visitor, it’s a gathering place where you can immerse yourself in the essence of Nantucket. The coastal fare and relaxed atmosphere transport you to the idyllic Nantucket dockside, where the best of both coasts converges.

From delectable New England-style lobster rolls to the zest of California Baja-style fish tacos, the menu encapsulates the island’s essence, delivering flavors and memories that echo the seaside charm of Nantucket itself. Just like Millie’s namesake, the cocktails here whisk you away to a state of mind where the sea meets the horizon, evoking the true Nantucket experience. Millie’s Market-Nantucket is more than just a seafood market; it’s a journey into the heart and soul of Nantucket’s coastal spirit.

8. Cru

Address: 1 Straight Wharf
City/State: Nantucket, Massachusetts

CRU, a Nantucket seafood market, has been a culinary beacon on the island since its establishment in May 2012. Nestled in the heart of Nantucket Harbor, CRU boasts an iconic waterfront location that sets the stage for an unparalleled dining experience. From the morning’s first light to the evening’s gentle sunset, this casually elegant venue offers a unique setting for indulging in the finest seafood offerings.

Whether you’re in the mood for a glass of champagne, a taste of exquisite caviar, or perfectly shucked oysters, CRU has you covered. The seafood selection at CRU is not just a meal; it’s an experience that captures the essence of Nantucket’s maritime charm. With a commitment to impeccable service, quality, and ambiance, CRU has become a culinary destination that stands alone on the island, making it a must-visit spot for all seafood enthusiasts exploring Nantucket.

In Seafood Paradise, You Have Choices

In this seafood paradise, these Nantucket meat and fish markets offer not only the freshest catches of the day but also a unique experience that captures the essence of this enchanting island. Whether you’re a local resident or a visitor, these markets have been satisfying seafood lovers for years, each with its distinctive charm and specialties.

From the casual elegance of CRU to the charming local touch at Sayle’s Seafood, the Nantucket seafood markets cater to every palate and craving. Exploring the island’s culinary delights wouldn’t be complete without venturing into these seafood havens, ensuring a memorable and delectable seafood journey on Nantucket.

The only way to get fresher fish would be to take a Fishing Charter from Nantucket.