15 Best Cape Cod Seafood Market

November 03, 2023

Cape Cod, with its picturesque coastline and rich maritime heritage, is a seafood lover’s paradise. The Cape’s pristine waters teem with an abundance of fresh catches, from succulent lobster to flavorful clam chowder. For those seeking the quintessential Cape Cod dining experience, a visit to its seafood markets is a must. These seafood markets are more than just purveyors of oceanic treasures; they are gateways to the Cape’s culinary traditions.

In this article, we embark on a culinary journey to explore the Top 15 Cape Cod Seafood Markets. Each of these markets offers an array of delights from the sea, ensuring that visitors and locals alike can savor the essence of Cape Cod’s coastal cuisine. Whether you’re in the mood for a lobster bake, a seafood boil, or the freshest catch of the day, these markets have you covered. Join us as we dive into the Cape’s seafood scene and discover the finest places to procure and enjoy the fruits of the ocean.

1. Chatham Pier Fish Market

Address: 45 Barcliff Avenue Ext
City/State: Chatham, Massachusetts

Located on the easternmost point of Massachusetts, Chatham Pier Fish Market boasts a prime position for seafood aficionados. It’s not just a place to savor delectable lobster rolls and crispy fried clams; it’s an immersive seafood experience. Sit at one of the inviting picnic tables and witness local fishermen unloading their daily catches, all while soaking up the sun’s warmth. And if you’re lucky, you might even catch a glimpse of the playful seals that frequent the area.

This iconic market traces its roots back over half a century, founded by the legendary Willard Nickerson, fondly known as “The Cod father.” In the 1950s, it started as Nickerson’s Fish and Lobster in a small building next to the Fish Pier. For generations, visitors and locals have flocked to Chatham Pier Fish Market for its unparalleled selection of fresh shellfish, lobsters, and locally sourced fish, all delivered straight from the boats moored nearby.

2. Young’s Fish Market

Address: 113 Rock Harbor Rd
City/State: Orleans, Massachusetts

Young’s Fish Market, nestled by the picturesque Rock Harbor docks in Orleans, MA, is a seafood haven for both visitors and locals. The location alone is a treat, offering views of charter boats and the tranquil waterfront as you shop. What sets Young’s Fish Market apart is its commitment to quality and freshness. From lobster rolls to a variety of fresh catches, including lobster and shellfish, this market ensures that your seafood cravings are met with the finest offerings from the sea.

Whether you’re planning a delightful lunch or a sumptuous dinner, Young’s is the go-to destination. The catch of the day is always on the menu, and the market’s dedication to quality and flavor makes it a top choice for seafood enthusiasts on Cape Cod. Young’s Fish Market on Cape Cod provides not only delectable seafood but also a quintessential experience, where every bite is a taste of the ocean’s bounty.

3. Breakwater Fish & Lobster Market

Address: 235 Underpass Rd
City/State: Brewster, Massachusetts

Breakwater Fish & Lobster Market, nestled in the heart of Cape Cod, stands as a testament to the authentic Cape Cod seafood experience. Owned by native Cape Codder Curt Collias, this market enjoys a distinct advantage – a direct line to the region’s rich seafood bounty. As a seafood wholesaler for local markets and restaurants, Breakwater Fish & Lobster Market ensures a constant supply of the freshest catches, making it a seafood haven for locals and visitors.

With the guarantee of freshness, Breakwater offers a delightful array of seafood treasures. From lobsters that practically leap from the ocean onto your plate to succulent fish that’s nothing short of a maritime masterpiece, the market exemplifies the Cape’s culinary traditions. Whether you’re planning a seafood feast or looking to savor the flavors of the Cape, Breakwater Fish & Lobster Market is the go-to destination for the frshest and the best seafood Cape Cod has to offer.

4. The Friendly Fisherman Restaurant & Seafood Market

Address: 4580 Route 6
City/State: Eastham, Massachusetts

The Friendly Fisherman Restaurant is a Seafood Market & the best restaurant in cape cod, where seafood enthusiasts’ dreams come true. This establishment combines the convenience of a seafood market with the pleasures of a restaurant, offering visitors a comprehensive seafood experience.

At the market, you can find an array of Cape Cod’s finest seafood, from shellfish to freshly caught fish fillets. What sets The Friendly Fisherman apart is their commitment to freshness. Local fishermen deliver seafood throughout the day, which is then expertly cut on-site and made available for purchase or prepared in the restaurant.

Their inventory is meticulously managed to ensure that your seafood shopping experience is free of any “fishy” odors. Whether you’re in the mood for lobsters, fruit, produce, fresh bread, or delectable pies, you’ll find it all here.

5. Andrea’s West Yarmouth Fish and Lobster

Address: 679 Rte. 28
City/State: West Yarmouth

Whenever you find yourself near South Yarmouth on Cape Cod, a seafood pilgrimage to Andrea’s West Yarmouth Fish and Lobster becomes a non-negotiable stop. This establishment consistently delivers the freshest, most delectable seafood, making it a cherished gem among locals and visitors alike.

Andrea’s is synonymous with quality, with their Faro Island Salmon standing out as the sweetest and most succulent you can find anywhere. Fresh Cod is a must-have, and for special occasions, their sweet lobster meat is a game-changer for crafting Lobster Rolls that impress even the most discerning guests.

On a balmy summer evening, the perfect light dinner includes their shrimp cocktail paired with homemade guacamole. The seafood selection is unparalleled, and the staff’s expertise and friendliness elevate the experience. Andrea’s West Yarmouth Fish and Lobster is not just a seafood market; it’s a culinary destination that leaves you coming back for more.

6. Swan River Restaurant & Fish Market

Address: 5 Lower County Road
City/State: Dennisport, Massachusetts

Since 1954, the Swan River Restaurant & Fish Market has been the go-to source for seafood in Dennis, and it’s easy to understand why. Voted the best seafood market in the mid-Cape region, Swan River offers the freshest seafood you can find on the Cape.

What sets Swan River apart is its commitment to freshness and quality. They purchase lobsters directly from local lobstermen and even maintain their own lobster tanks. Whether you’re in the mood for a 1-pound lobster or a 5+ pound feast, Swan River has you covered. They’ll even cook and crack your lobsters at no extra charge, ensuring a hassle-free dining experience.

7. Wimpy’s Seafood

Address: 752 Main St
City/State: Osterville, Massachusetts

Wimpy’s Seafood, established in 1938 as a modest hamburger counter, has evolved over the years into a beloved Cape Cod institution. Located in Osterville, this familyowned gem remains unwavering in its commitment to community, hospitality, and exceptional food quality.

With over 200 seats and a thriving retail/take-out market, Wimpy’s is more than a seafood destination: it’s a cherished tradition. The restaurant offers a choice of three distinct rooms, each featuring fireside dining – from the cozy tavern and bar to the elegant Cahoon Room with its fieldstone fireplace.

8. Cape Tip Seafood Market

Address: 300 Rt 6
City/State: Truro, Massachusetts

Cape Tip Seafood Market, nestled in Truro, has carved out a special place in the hearts of both locals and visitors. Their unwavering commitment to quality, fresh seafood, and their expertise in the world of oceanic delights are truly remarkable.

From creating your own clambakes to savoring delectable lobster rolls and hot clam chowder, Cape Tip offers the finest seafood experiences. Their selection of fresh fish, sourced from local fishing boats in Provincetown, Truro, and Wellfleet, is nothing short of impressive. Daily deliveries of tuna, swordfish, salmon, and more from major northeast ports ensure you receive the freshest catches.

9. Osterville Fish Market

Address: 2952 Falmouth Rd
City/State: Osterville, Massachusetts

For over two decades, Osterville Fish Market has epitomized the essence of topnotch cape cod seafood market. Opening their doors in 1998 with a simple yet ambitious goal – to be the very best – they’ve remained true to their mission.

Their success lies in unwavering dedication to quality and customer service. They offer a delectable array of superior fish and shellfish, including Cape Cod favorites like lobsters, oysters, and clams. But what truly sets them apart is the smiles they bring to their customers’ faces.

Osterville Fish is not just a business; it’s a part of the Cape Cod community. Their active involvement in local programs and support for various organizations reflects their commitment to the people who’ve embraced them. They’ve created a legacy of freshness, quality, and community spirit that continues to shine on Cape Cod.

10.Cape Fish & Lobster

Address: 626 W Main St
City/State: Hyannis, Massachusetts

Stumbling upon Cape Fish & Lobster feels like discovering a hidden treasure. This place is a testament to their commitment to educating and satisfying every seafood lover.

Their abundant variety of seafood options is rivaled only by the knowledge and helpfulness of the staff. The ability to order fresh lobster dinners, perfectly prepared, is a convenience that captures your heart. Whether you’re a seafood enthusiast or a newbie, this is a place of endless discovery.

Their tanks house impressively large live lobsters, some exceeding 10 pounds, a true spectacle for seafood aficionados. The delight doesn’t stop there; their offerings span from fully prepared crab cakes and large shrimp to savory smoked fish and beyond.

11.Lobster Trap Fish Market

Address: 290 Shore Rd
City/State: Bourne, Massachusetts

Lobster Trap is a hidden gem among the cape cod seafood markets. Their unwavering commitment to freshness and quality shines through in every aspect of their business. It’s a place where you can trust that you’re getting the best the local waters have to offer. The standout feature is their live lobsters, ensuring each order, no matter the size, is fulfilled. They even offer the convenience of cooking them for you, allowing you to enjoy these succulent crustaceans with ease.

But Lobster Trap isn’t just about lobsters. Their selection of seafood is impressive, from cod and haddock to swordfish and scallops. The knowledgeable staff provides guidance and assistance, ensuring you leave with the perfect catch. Lobster Trap epitomizes Cape Cod’s seafood tradition and is a must-visit for anyone craving the freshest flavors of the sea.

12.Green Pond Fish Market

Address: 767 E Falmouth Hwy
City/State: East Falmouth, Massachusetts

Green Pond Fish Market is a beacon of quality seafood on Cape Cod. As a familyowned establishment, their commitment to providing the very best and freshest seafood is unwavering. Cap’n Dick’s journey from a canteen truck to the Kenyon’s Corner deli and eventually to Green Pond Fish ‘n Gear is a testament to his dedication to Falmouth’s seafood scene. Cap’n Bob, following in his father’s footsteps, maintains the legacy of excellence. Although they had to bid farewell to fishing tackle, their focus on seafood quality has never been sharper. At Green Pond Fish Market, you’ll taste seafood as it’s meant to be truly exceptional. For locals and visitors, it’s a taste of Cape Cod’s finest.

13.Cotuit Oyster Company

Address: 26 Little River Rd
City/State: Cotuit, Massachusetts

Cotuit Oyster Company stands as a testament to the best seafood on Cape Cod. Renowned for their distinctive briny flavor, Cotuit oysters are in a league of their own. The oysters’ unique taste owes its character to the freshwater streams, marshes, and estuaries, coupled with the pristine waters of Nantucket Sound. This combination produces oysters with a moderate salinity, averaging 2930 parts per thousand (PPT), and a remarkable sweet finish.

Cotuit Oyster Company’s commitment to quality has garnered recognition far beyond Cape Cod, with oyster enthusiasts from all corners of the world seeking out these exceptional bivalves. It’s a testament to the Cape’s rich seafood heritage, making it a must-visit destination for any seafood aficionado.

14.Hatch’s Fish Market

Address: 310 Main St
City/State: Wellfleet, Massachusetts

Hatch’s Fish Market stands as a testament to the Cape’s rich seafood tradition. For over six decades, this family-owned establishment has provided Wellfleet and its visitors with a delightful array of seafood and produce. Their daily selection, sourced from local species, guarantees the freshest seafood you can find on the Cape. Whether it’s fish, lobsters, shellfish, or smoked fish, Hatch’s commitment to quality is evident in every product they offer.

Their dedication to the community extends to their extensive produce section, offering a wide variety of organic and locally grown fruits and vegetables. With over 50 types of produce, fresh bread, herbs, and salad greens, Hatch’s is the go-to destination for all your culinary needs on Cape Cod. When you’re seeking the finest ingredients for a memorable meal, Hatch’s Fish and Produce Market is the place to be.

15.Cataumet Fish

Address: 1360 Rte. 28A
City/State: Cataumet, Massachusetts

Cataumet Fish is a seafood lover’s paradise. Their commitment to sourcing highquality, responsibly harvested, and exceptionally fresh local seafood is evident the moment you step inside. You’ll witness fishermen delivering their daily catch, reinforcing the market’s dedication to freshness. The menu features a delightful array of daily catches and seasonal specialties, along with convenient grab-and-go and prepared options.

What sets Cataumet Fish apart is its specialty market experience. In addition to offering top-notch seafood, they’ve curated a selection of small-batch retail food items and ingredients, both locally sourced and internationally inspired, designed to enhance your seafood dishes.

From Bourne to Provincetown: The Top 15 Cape Cod Seafood Markets

Cape Cod is a seafood paradise, and its seafood markets are the jewels of its culinary crown. From Falmouth to Provincetown, these top fifteen seafood markets have proven their commitment to delivering the freshest, tastiest seafood to locals and visitors alike. Whether you’re looking for the finest lobsters, the plumpest oysters, or the catch of the day, you’ll find

it in these markets. These businesses aren’t just about seafood; they’re about community, quality, and service. Cape Cod’s seafood markets aren’t just places to buy dinner; they’re where memories are made, where flavors come to life, and where seafood lovers unite to celebrate the treasures of the sea.