Top 7 Nantucket Liquor Stores And Local Wine Shops

November 03, 2023

Nantucket with its picturesque beaches and charming streets,  is not only a haven for summertime bliss but also a destination that offers a delightful selection of local wine shop and liquor shops. These establishments are more than just places to purchase libations; they are woven into the fabric of the island’s culture, each with its own unique character and offerings.

From historic wine cellars to contemporary spirits boutiques, nantucket liquor stores and the local wine shops cater to both residents and visitors alike. Join us on a journey to explore seven of these gems, where you can find exceptional wines, craft spirits, and expert guidance from knowledgeable staff.

Nantucket Liquor Stores And The Local Wine Shops

1. Siasconset Bookstore Wines

Address: 8 Main St
City/State/Zip Code: Nantucket, Ma 02554

Found right on the beautiful island of Nantucket, Siasconset Bookstore Wines isn’t just a local wine shop and  liquor shop; it’s a heartfelt tribute to the island’s rich history and the spirit of a Nantucket summer. Run by a family deeply rooted in the island’s culture, the shop exudes a warm and inviting atmosphere that encapsulates the essence of the Nantucket experience.

From their beloved Sconset Café to their venture at Siasconset Bookstore Wines, the owners aim to foster a sense of community and camaraderie. They understand the importance of celebrations and social gatherings, making sure that your beverage selection is never a mundane choice. The shop boasts a carefully curated selection of favorite beers, wines, and liquors while also embracing new and exciting options.

Whether you’re planning a beachside gathering or a memorable island soirée, Siasconset Bookstore Wines has everything you need to create cherished summer memories. As Julia Child wisely noted, “A party without a cocktail is just a meeting,” and this shop ensures your gatherings are nothing short of celebrations.

2. Current Vintage

Address: 4 Easy St
City/State/Zip Code: Nantucket, Ma 02554

Current Vintage, a true gem on Nantucket Island, has earned its reputation as a beloved wine, clothing, and home store over its impressive 16-year history. Founded by Beth English and supported by Sommelier Savannah Johnson, Current Vintage is a one-stop destination for all your wine, vintage, and lifestyle needs.

When it comes to wine, Current Vintage’s selection is nothing short of exceptional, boasting nearly 400 wines, both from small, artisanal producers and iconic winemakers. Their handpicked assortment caters to all price points, ensuring there’s a bottle for every occasion. To complement their wine program, you can find farmstead cheese, charcuterie, artisanal snacks, and craft beers.

Noteworthy in the world of retail, Current Vintage has been featured and recognized by distinguished publications like Forbes, In Style, Food & Wine, Vogue, and more. It’s also a proud recipient of accolades such as “Best Boutique” of the Cape and Islands by Boston Magazine and the Silver Medal for “Best Liquor/Wine Store 2022” by Cape Cod Life Magazine.

With its stellar reputation, Current Vintage has certainly solidified its place as a must-visit shop for those looking to enhance their Nantucket experience with top-quality wines, vintage fashion, and stylish home goods.

3. Epernay Wine & Spirits

Address: 1 North Beach Street
City/State/Zip Code: Nantucket, Ma 02554

Epernay Wine & Spirits is truly a jewel in Nantucket’s wine scene, and it’s easy to see why. Owned and operated by sommeliers, Jenny Benzie and Kirk Baker, this wine and spirits shop stands out as a beacon of expertise and passion. Jenny Benzie, with her impressive credentials as an Advanced Sommelier, Certified Wine Educator, and Diploma of Wine & Spirits holder, brings a wealth of experience from working at renowned restaurants nationwide.

Her partner in wine, Kirk Baker, is a Certified Sommelier with a deep understanding of the wine business, having worked in various roles within the industry. With their combined knowledge and love for wine, they’ve created a haven for wine enthusiasts and beginners alike.

The selection at Epernay Wine & Spirits is meticulously curated, offering a diverse range of wines and spirits from around the world. Whether you’re seeking the perfect wine pairing for a special dinner or looking for a unique spirit to enjoy, Jenny, Kirk, and their knowledgeable staff are there to guide you through your choices.

Epernay’s commitment to providing a personalized and educational experience sets them apart. Their dedication to helping customers discover the right libations for any occasion is evident. If you’re visiting Nantucket, make sure to stop by this exceptional wine and spirits shop. You’ll not only find exquisite libations but also passionate experts ready to assist you on your wine and spirits journey.

4. Brix Nantucket

Address: 1 Windy Ave
City/State/Zip Code: Nantucket, Ma 02554

Brix Nantucket is more than just a local wine shop and liquor store; it’s a labor of love by two best friends who share a passion for wine, food, and perfectly crafted cocktails. Their journey began in 2003 when they set out to create a space that goes beyond your typical wine shop. It’s a place where you not only buy a bottle of wine but also immerse yourself in an exceptional experience.

The shop exudes warmth and invites you to hang out, explore, and savor the world of wines and spirits. The owners, with their keen taste and extensive travels, hand-pick a selection of bottles that tell unique stories. They believe in building relationships, not just with their customers but also with winemakers, distributors, and their dedicated staff.

When you step into Brix Nantucket, you’re not just buying a libation; you’re entering a world where each bottle has a voice, a story, and a personal touch. This shop is a testament to their commitment to quality, customer service, and creating memorable moments for everyone who walks through their door.

5. Hatch’s Package Store

Address: 133 Orange Street
City/State/Zip Code: Nantucket

Hatch’s Package Store, nestled in the heart of Nantucket, is not just a liquor store; it’s a piece of island history. This charming establishment traces its roots back to the early 1900s when it began as a garage selling kerosene for heating and later transitioned to offer gasoline with the rise of automobiles. The end of Prohibition brought about a significant change as Hatch’s acquired a beer and wine license. The 1960s saw Katherine Hatch Dunham take the reins, followed by the store’s sale to Judith and Butler Brownell in 1979.

In 1984, recognizing the need for expansion, Hatch’s built a larger store, setting the stage for its modern-day presence. Today, it not only stocks a wide selection of popular beers and wines but can also procure rare and hard-to-find offerings. Hatch’s Package Store is your go-to destination for all your beverage needs, whether you’re planning a backyard barbecue or an elegant and special occasion. It’s a testament to the island’s history and a place where you can find the perfect libations to make your moments on Nantucket memorable.

6. Nantucket Wine & Spirits

Address: 31 Sparks Avenue
City/State/Zip Code: Nantucket, Ma 02554

Nantucket Wine & Spirits is truly a gem among Nantucket’s local wine and liquor shops. This year-round, family-owned establishment has been delighting island residents and visitors for four decades. With a handpicked selection of wines, craft beers, and spirits sourced from around the globe, they have made it their mission to bring the world’s best libations to the shores of Nantucket.

What sets this shop apart is the genuine commitment to the island community. They offer special orders, convenient deliveries, and a dedicated focus on serving their clients. Whether you’re seeking the perfect bottle for a special occasion or a daily sip, you’ll find knowledgeable and passionate staff, led by the mother-daughter duo of Mary and Alanna.

Alanna’s return to Nantucket, after honing her skills in the wine business in California, has injected new life and expertise into this beloved shop. Her boundless wine knowledge and fresh enthusiasm ensure that Nantucket Wine & Spirits remains a top destination for discerning wine and spirit enthusiasts on the island. Open seven days a week, with both in-store pickup and delivery services, it’s clear that they provide a comprehensive and convenient wine shopping experience.

7. Islander Package Store

Address: 15 Old South Rd
City/State/Zip Code: Nantucket, Ma 02554

Islander Package Store, a cherished gem among Nantucket’s local wine shop and liquor stores, beckons with the promise of a remarkable libation experience. As you step inside, you are greeted by a wealth of choices and a warm, friendly atmosphere. Family-owned and operated, The Islander is dedicated to delivering the most extensive and finest selection of wines and spirits on the island.
Their commitment to providing top-notch customer service is evident in the helpful smiles and the wealth of knowledge shared with each visitor. Whether you’re on the hunt for a rare single malt Scotch, a carefully curated microbrew, or a fine hand-rolled cigar to complement your libation, The Islander has you covered.

Open year-round, seven days a week, The Islander Package Store is your go-to destination for a wide range of libations. Their convenient hours ensure that you can explore their offerings at your leisure, always accompanied by attentive and informed staff. The Islander is more than a store; it’s a haven for those who appreciate quality and a warm, welcoming environment. Don’t miss the opportunity to experience this exceptional Nantucket establishment.

Vibrant Spirit of Wine and Nantucket Liquor Stores

Whether you’re planning an intimate beachfront picnic or a celebratory event, Nantucket’s local shops have your libation needs covered.  The island’s vibrant spirit extends to the local wine shop and liquor stores on Nantucket that offer a diverse range of libations and unique experiences.

These local establishments take pride in their selections, expertise, and the personal touch they bring to each customer interaction. Whether you’re looking for fine wines, rare spirits, craft beers, or exclusive cigars, you’ll find it all in Nantucket.

The local wine shop and liquor stores on Nantucket not only cater to the connoisseurs but also provide guidance for the curious. They’re more than just stores; they’re integral parts of the community, reflecting the island’s culture, hospitality, and dedication to delivering exceptional libation experiences. Visit these establishments and discover Nantucket’s true spirit in a bottle.