Discover Top 10 Martha's Vineyard Grocery Stores

Martha’s Vineyard, with its serene landscapes and close-knit communities, has always celebrated its connection to local businesses. One way to experience this bond is by visiting the local grocery stores Martha’s Vineyard that thrive. Unlike large supermarket chains, these stores provide a more personal and tailored shopping experience.

From freshly baked bread to locally caught seafood, you’ll find a delightful array of goods that represent the island’s culture and culinary traditions. Whether you’re a resident or a visitor, these ten martha’s vineyard grocery stores are worth exploring. They showcase the unique character of the island, its dedication to quality, and its strong community spirit, making your grocery shopping a truly delightful part of the Vineyard experience.

The Best Martha’s Vineyard Grocery Stores

1. Cronig’s Market

Address: 357 State Road
City/State: Vineyard Haven, Massachusetts

Cronig’s Market, a cherished fixture on Martha’s Vineyard since 1917, exemplifies the essence of a family-owned grocery store. With two convenient locations in Vineyard Haven and West Tisbury, Cronig’s has cemented its reputation for advocating local farmers and producers, making it a go-to destination for those in pursuit of organic and locally sourced goods.

Their inventory boasts an impressive array of offerings, from farm-fresh, seasonal fruits and vegetables to artisanal cheeses, freshly baked bread, and an expansive selection of specialty items. Cronig’s Market goes beyond being a simple grocery store; it’s a treasure trove for food enthusiasts who value high-quality, locally inspired ingredients. For a genuine taste of Martha’s Vineyard, look no further than Cronig’s.

2. Chilmark General Store

Address: 7 State Road
City/State: Chilmark, Massachusetts

Chilmark General Store is more than just a local grocery shop; it’s a heartwarming community hub on Martha’s Vineyard. This welcoming store offers an array of everyday essentials, fresh local produce, and household necessities. Whether you’re seeking breakfast, lunch, or dinner, they have you covered. You can savor organic, small batch roasted coffee and delight in sandwiches made with bread from PainD’Avignon bakery. The real standout is their famous hand-tossed pizza, adorned with carefully selected ingredients like fresh mozzarella and imported Italian meats.

Chilmark General Store’s mission is simple: to provide the best possible experience for its customers. Located near Beetlebung corner, it’s a place where you can refuel and relax on the porch while enjoying a delicious meal. They embrace good, simple food and prioritize sourcing from local growers, producers, and sustainable sources.

Set in the tranquil and picturesque community of Chilmark, this store is a testament to what makes Martha’s Vineyard special. The serene landscapes, rolling hills, historic fishing village of Menemsha, and breathtaking sunsets all make it a remarkable destination. Chilmark General Store perfectly encapsulates the island’s charm and warmth.

3. Black Sheep Mercantile

Address: 17 Airport Road
City/State: Edgartown, Massachusetts

Black Sheep Mercantile, situated near the Martha’s Vineyard airport, is a hidden gem for those seeking unique and gourmet provisions on the island. This charming grocery store stands out with its thoughtfully curated selection of seasonal offerings. From delightful snacks to an assortment of frozen foods, baked goods, and pantry staples, Black Sheep Mercantile has it all.

One of the store’s standout features is its delectable range of prepared foods. Whether you’re in the mood for a fresh salad, a satisfying sandwich, or a mouthwatering entree, you’ll find a diverse selection that’s ready to go. The convenience of well-prepared, high-quality meals makes Black Sheep Mercantile a go-to spot for Martha’s Vineyard residents and visitors alike.

4. Grey Barn Farm

Address: 22 South Road
City/State: Chilmark, Massachusetts

Grey Barn Farm is an idyllic haven nestled in the scenic town of Chilmark on Martha’s Vineyard. This remarkable farmstand is more than just a place to shop; it’s a celebration of sustainable farming practices and a testament to their commitment to quality. Step inside, and you’ll be greeted by an array of farm-fresh products, from eggs and vegetables to yogurts, fresh milk, and meats. What sets Grey Barn Farm apart is its emphasis on sourcing items either from their own farm or local producers who share their dedication to sustainability.

The farm’s ethos revolves around a holistic approach to land, animals, and people.
Their certified organic land, hormone-free and antibiotic-free animal raising, nonGMO produce, and natural heritage-breed ingredients in their bread showcase a deep respect for nature and quality. Visitors and locals alike flock to Grey Barn Farm not just for its exceptional dairy products but to experience a genuine connection to the land.

Grey Barn Farm’s dedication to regenerative agricultural practices underscores their commitment to environmental sustainability, land stewardship, and carbon sequestration, ensuring that their farm remains a symbol of responsible and sustainable agriculture. It’s a place where appreciation, love for the land, and a profound respect for the community converge to create a true farm-to-table haven.

5. Alley’s General Store

Address: 1045 State Rd
City/State/Zip Code: West Tisbury, MA 02575

Alley’s General Store, established in 1858, is a timeless gem on Martha’s Vineyard. It stands as a testament to history, enduring as the island’s oldest retail business and a treasured gathering place. Stepping into this charming store is like entering a time capsule, preserving its original character.

Alley’s General Store has maintained its reputation as “dealers in almost everything” over the years. It offers a diverse range of products, from fresh produce to delectable snacks, candies, household essentials, souvenirs, and more. Wandering through the narrow aisles is an adventure, where you can uncover hidden treasures nestled on the shelves. Alley’s General Store remains a beloved establishment, making it a must-visit for both locals and tourists.

6. Morning Glory Farm

Address: 290 West Tisbury Rd
City/State: Edgartown

Morning Glory Farm is an agricultural gem on Martha’s Vineyard. Located just outside downtown Edgartown, it seamlessly combines the charm of a working farm with a bustling farmstand. With 70 acres of farmland at their disposal, you can explore rows of fresh, vibrant vegetables, fruits, and herbs, all recently plucked from the earth.

What truly sets this place apart is the on-site bakery that churns out an array of mouthwatering delights. Pies, quiches, and breads, all crafted using the farm’s own produce, offer a genuine taste of the island’s agricultural richness. Morning Glory Farm is not just a farm, but a celebration of Martha’s Vineyard’s flavors, and visiting it is an opportunity to immerse yourself in the island’s culinary and agricultural delights.

7. Katama General Store

Address: 170 Katama Rd
City/State/Zip Code: Edgartown, MA 02539

Katama General Store is your one-stop destination for a perfect beach day on Martha’s Vineyard. Their extensive selection of beach essentials, including chairs, towels, sunscreen, umbrellas, sunglasses, and beach toys, ensures that you’re fully equipped for a fantastic day by the sea.

Owned by the dynamic duo Jackie and Doug Korell, Katama General Store has been a cherished part of the island for over two decades. It all began in a small red shack, and today, their business, including the famed Lobster Tales catering service, continues to thrive.

The store is renowned for serving the best Lobster Rolls on the island, complemented by a delectable range of made-to-order salads and sandwiches available in the Grab & Go section. Whether you’re visiting Martha’s Vineyard or heading to South Beach, Katama General Store has you covered with everything you need.

8. Healthy Additions

Address: 31 Colonial Dr,
City/State: Vineyard Haven, Massachusetts

Healthy Additions, located just behind Cronig’s Market in Vineyard Haven, is a haven for health-conscious individuals and anyone with specific dietary needs. This well-rounded health store offers a diverse range of products, including natural supplements, health foods, organic snacks, pet supplies, bulk herbs, spices, and teas. It’s your one-stop destination for everything from wellness essentials to home goods.

With over 17,000 thoughtfully curated products on two floors, Healthy Additions is your go-to place for supplements, health-conscious groceries, and unique gifts. The store continually adapts to the latest health trends and discoveries, ensuring you have access to the best products. The friendly and knowledgeable staff is always ready to assist, making your shopping experience enjoyable and informative. Furthermore, Healthy Additions’ existence is thanks to the support and back-office assistance provided by Cronig’s Market, showcasing their commitment to the community’s health and well-being.

9. The Gay Head Store Aquinnah

Address: 33 Aquinnah Circle
City/State: Aquinnah, Massachusetts

The Gay Head Store is a hidden gem on Martha’s Vineyard, especially if you’re exploring the scenic up-Island area. Situated near the iconic Gay Head Lighthouse, this store is a convenient and much-needed stop for those in the region. Rather than embarking on a lengthy journey to Edgartown or Oak Bluffs, visitors can stock up on essential supplies right here.

The store offers a range of locally sourced produce, baked goods, and premade sandwiches, making it a one-stop-shop for both locals and tourists. Its strategic location near the picturesque Gay Head Lighthouse makes it a must-visit for those looking to combine practical shopping with sightseeing, ensuring that your Martha’s Vineyard adventure is both convenient and memorable.

Providing Residents and Visitors the Taste of Martha’s Vineyard Grocery Stores

The delightful array of local grocery stores in Martha’s Vineyard, each booasting their own unique character and offerings. From Morning Glory Farm, where the farmstand overflows with fresh produce and delectable baked goods, to Alley’s General Store, steeped in history and stocked with everything you might need, these shops play a crucial role in preserving the island’s distinct charm.

They provide residents and visitors alike with a taste of Martha’s Vineyard’s rich agricultural heritage, offering a wide range of products, many of which are sourced locally. Whether you’re a local seeking essential or a visitor eager to savor the island’s flavors, these grocery stores in Martha’s Vineyard provide a delightful shopping experience, connecting you to the heart of the island’s culture and community.