Top 6 Grocery Stores In Nantucket

Nantucket, with its timeless charm and unique island spirit, offers not only breathtaking beaches and historic architecture but also a range of local grocery shops that add to the island’s allure. These establishments are more than just places to pick up essentials; they are vital components of the island’s community and character.

From classic markets with a touch of nostalgia to contemporary stores that embrace innovation and local sourcing, the grocery stores in Nantucket have a lot to offer. This article will take you on a journey through the top six Nantucket grocery stores, exploring what makes each one a cherished part of Nantucket’s lifestyle. Whether you’re a resident or a visitor, these stores invite you to experience the island’s culinary and cultural diversity.

Local Grocery Stores In Nantucket

1. The Green Market Nantucket

Address: 4 India St
City/State/Zip Code: Nantucket, Ma 02554

The Green Market Nantucket is more than just a grocery store; it’s a testament to the power of friendship, sustainability, and wellness. Co-founded by Tessa Cressman and Jenny Bence, this establishment is the embodiment of their shared passion for food, design, and community. Tessa’s creative flair and Jenny’s culinary expertise have merged to create a space that beautifully captures all that Nantucket has to offer.

This year-round marketplace provides an essential platform for local vendors to showcase their products while offering residents and visitors a convenient one-stop shopping destination. The emphasis on supporting small businesses and sourcing products from New England reflects The Green Market’s commitment to the community and sustainability.

2. Bartlett’s Farm

Address: 33 Bartlett Farm Rd
City/State/Zip Code: Nantucket, Ma 02554

Bartlett’s Farm on Nantucket is an institution that encapsulates the essence of local, family-owned businesses. As the island’s oldest and largest family-owned farm, Bartlett’s Farm takes great pride in offering an extensive selection of fresh, locally grown vegetables, flowers, plants, and event facilities. Their Market is the hub where all their incredible produce, renowned farm-grown corn, tomatoes, and a wide array of goods come together, creating a one-stop destination for shoppers.

While summer visitors can enjoy the bounties fresh from the fields and greenhouses, year-round shoppers will find regionally sourced and carefully chosen produce to craft delicious recipes. Bartlett’s Farm excels in offering high-quality pantry staples, dairy, meats, and more, with an emphasis on organic, small-batch, and regional products. The market’s dedication to supporting local growers, suppliers, and purveyors ensures you’ll find a wide range of unique and exceptional items, including artisanal cheeses, local honey, boutique olive oils, and more on their shelves, year-round.

3. Fresh Nantucket

Address: 5 Salem St
City/State/Zip Code: Nantucket, Ma 02254

Fresh Nantucket is truly the “everything store of treats” on the island. With a diverse range of offerings, it caters to a variety of tastes and preferences. Their upscale deli stands out with an enticing selection of sandwiches, salads, and smoothies that promise a delightful meal or snack.

What makes Fresh Nantucket even more appealing is its full liquor store, boasting an impressive collection of spirits, fine wines, beers, and ready-to-drink beverages. This convenience is complemented by a delectable assortment of prepared foods and an extensive cheese and charcuterie spread.

4. Sconset Market

Address: 4 Main St
City/State/Zip Code: Nantucket, Ma 02254

Sconset Market is more than just a grocery store; it’s a cherished village market, brimming with delightful finds. As soon as you step inside, you’ll be greeted by a diverse range of products, from groceries to unique gifts and homewares.

This market is the heartbeat of the village, where regulars gather for morning coffee and freshly baked treats. Stop in to pick up a picnic on your way to Sconset Beach.

It’s the ideal spot for a post-supper ice cream cone, a delightful tradition for many. What sets Sconset Market apart is its exclusive selection of privately labeled items, including jams, salsas, condiments, dressings, and marinades – all of which you won’t find anywhere else.

5. Nantucket Meat & Fish Market

Address: 21 Old South Rd,
City/State: Nantucket, Massachusetts

Nantucket Meat & Fish Market, a family-owned and operated gem on Nantucket, is a testament to exceptional service and quality. Committed to providing their customers with the absolute best, the market offers a warm and personalized shopping experience. The staff is always ready to assist, answer questions, and accommodate special orders, ensuring that each visit is both convenient and enjoyable.

This gourmet food market truly has it all – from fresh seafood and prime meats to a delightful selection of prepared foods. Whether you’re in the mood for a bagel from their bakery, a coffee at the café, sushi for lunch, or everyday groceries, Nantucket Meat & Fish Market has you covered. It’s the go-to destination for Nantucket residents and visitors alike who value premium quality and friendly service.

6. Nantucket Trading Post Inc

Address: 12 Nobadeer Farm Rd
City/State/Zip Code: Nantucket, Massachusetts

Nantucket Trading stands out as a local convenience store gem on Nantucket. This cozy grocery shop is a one-stop destination for both residents and visitors in need of daily essentials. The store, although unassuming, offers a wide range of products, making it a valuable part of the community.

From pantry staples to fresh produce, Nantucket Trading caters to a variety of needs, ensuring customers can easily access the items they require. The friendly staff adds a personal touch to your shopping experience, and their dedication to customer service sets the store apart.

If you’re looking for a hassle-free shopping experience with the charm of a local convenience store, Nantucket Trading is the place to visit. It’s an essential resource for anyone on Nantucket, ensuring you have everything you need at your fingertips.

Nantucket’s Commitment to Quality Produce

In the charming island of Nantucket, where community spirit and local charm prevail, the availability of exceptional local grocery shops adds to the island’s allure. These six local Nantucket grocery stores are not just places to pick up essentials; they are a testament to the island’s commitment to providing quality products and fostering a sense of community.

Whether you’re a longtime resident or a visitor seeking a taste of the island’s unique character, these grocery stores offer an authentic Nantucket experience. With their fresh produce, locally sourced goods, and friendly service, they reflect the heart and soul of the island.  Local grocery stores in Nantucket are not just places to shop; they are part of the island’s story, connecting residents and visitors alike with the spirit of this beautiful destination.

Read more to find the 8 Freshest Seafood Markets on Nantucket.