Martha’s Vineyard is known for its majestic coastline, wildflower fields, hiking paths, and the island flavors. There are some of the best seafood restaurants in Martha’s Vineyard and plenty of attractions that keep people hooked. This is a great vacation spot but all that fun and vacation results in a thirsty mouth and a hungry stomach.
Luckily, there are lots of casual restaurants on Martha’s Vineyard with something for everyone’s taste. Whether you’re a seafood lover or willing to have a hangout with family or friends, this place has all types of eateries.
Our pick for top casual restaurants on Martha’s Vineyard
1. The Red Cat Kitchen – Best for New American Dishes
Address: 6 Circuit Ave, Oak Bluffs, MA 02557, USA
Phone: +1 508-696-6040
The Red Cat Kitchen is one of the most popular restaurants in Oak Bluffs on Martha’s Vineyard. It offers a casual environment with a hanging TV and a perfect place to hang out. The restaurant uses locally sourced ingredients to create their delicious farm-and-sea-to-table menu. However, the menu keeps changing, but if you find scallops and risotto or oyster pan-fry there, don’t miss it. Besides that, the lobster salad is also perfect for a refreshing start. For the mains you must try seared tuna and shrimp curry and the salmon or sword over veggies with coconut curry sauce.
2. Among the Flowers Cafe – Best for Breakfast
Address: 17 Mayhew Ln, Edgartown, MA 02539, USA
Phone: +1 508-627-3233
If you love to eat in a peaceful environment among flowers, this restaurant is the perfect place to be. Among the Flowers Cafe has a beautiful outdoor patio surrounded by flowers and an indoor seating decorated with colorful paintings and vases. The restaurant offers a hearty menu for breakfast, lunch, and take-out. They have waffles, muffins, breakfast bowls, sandwiches, hashes, salads, and smoothies. Besides these, their coffee and latte is so good, pair them with your favorite sandwich or muffin and you’re good to go!
3. Linda Jean’s Restaurant – Best for Homemade American Dishes
Address: 25 Circuit Ave, Oak Bluffs, MA 02557, USA
Phone: +1 508-693-4093
Linda Jean’s Restaurant is one of the favorite eateries in Martha’s Vineyard for more than 40 years. The restaurant has a small cozy and laid-back atmosphere for all the casual eaters. The dining space is compact but there is ample seating and looks spacious because of light colored decor. The restaurant offers the best pancakes and french toast and other items for breakfast. Besides these, there are perfect lunch and dinner options too. For every meal there are specific plates, for example, breakfast plate, lunch plate, etc. Their salads, soups, and beverages are worth trying too!
4. Artcliff Diner – Best for Creative Dishes
Address: 39 Beach Rd, Vineyard Haven, MA 02568, United States
Phone: +1 508-693-1224
Artcliff Diner is known for its creative dishes and beautiful presentation. The restaurant features a Victorian-style decor and has a vintage ambience. Artcliff Diner offers an extensive menu and their best entrees are The Hen House Benedict, Macintosh and Almond pancake, chicken hash, and almond crusted French toast. This place is perfect for breakfast, but their lunch and dinner are excellent too.
5. The Grey Barn and Farm – Best for Breakfast
Address: 22 S Rd, Chilmark, MA 02535, USA
Phone: +1 508-645-4854
The Grey Barn and Farm is a perfect place for all the meat lovers out there. This is basically a barn and a farm, where small tables are arranged in the backyard for people to dine in. It has a bakery, creamery, livestock, and farmstand. Here you can get fresh bread, cheese, meats, and preserves. Best of all, you know that all their products are raised right on the farm and are fresh and organic.
People stop by this spot to enjoy yummy and generous breakfast options. The restaurant also offers private tours where you can explore and customize your breakfast by choosing from cheeses, breads, jams, and charcuterie.
6. Orange Peel Bakery – Best for Pizza
Address: 22 State Rd, Aquinnah, MA 02535, USA
Phone: +1 508-645-2025
The Orange Peel Bakery is a native-owned eatery located at the end of the south road in Aquinnah. They have a bakery and an outdoor location that offers delicious hand-tossed pizzas. You can eat the pizzas there or have a take-away. The menu of pizza is short and the pizza is 12 inches. They also offer BYOB Sunday dinners with mains like filet mignon and whole fish.
7. Biscuits – Best for Lunch
Address: 26 Lake Ave, Oak Bluffs, MA 02557, USA
Phone: +1 508-693-2033
Biscuits is a small and cozy bakery located in Oak Bluffs, Martha’s Vineyard. The bakery offers a perfect place to have breakfast or lunch. They offer delicious American cuisine including seafood and tasty desserts. The best entrees by this restaurant include the shrimp and grits, waffles, benedict, biscuits and gravy, omelets, sandwiches and pancakes.
8. Little House Cafe – Best for Vegetarians
Address: 339 State Rd, Vineyard Haven, MA 02568, USA
Phone: +1 508-687-9794
The Little House Cafe is a casual restaurant good for breakfast, lunch, and dinner in Martha’s Vineyard. The restaurant has a simple and minimalistic design and offers a laid-back atmosphere. You’ll find picnic tables neatly arranged at the bakery from where you can grab your favorite stuff. They offer a variety of soups, salads, baked items, bagels, wraps, and sandwiches at an affordable price. Their menu is vegetarian and Mediterranean based.
9. The Port Hunter – Best for Entertainment
Address: 55 Main St, Edgartown, MA 02539, USA
Phone: +1 508-627-7747
If you’re willing to enjoy your meal while music plays in the black in a lively atmosphere, The Port Hunter is a perfect place. The restaurant is a fun place to be and many locals and tourists visit the place to enjoy seafood. You can order from the Raw bar where they offer oysters and clams. Besides these, favorites include chicken sandwich, fish tacos, PH burger, Burrata, and baby back ribs.
10. The Black Dog Tavern – Best for Craft Cocktails
Address: 20 Beach Street Extension, Vineyard Haven, MA 02568, USA
Phone: +1 508-693-9223
The Black Dog Tavern is a casual restaurant located in Vineyard Haven, Martha’s Vineyard. The restaurant has indoor seating arrangement as well as an outdoor patio that provides harbor views. You can choose to have breakfast, lunch, or dinner at this restaurant and also enjoy the live music on the patio. The best entrees at this restaurant are Black Dog clam chowder, lobster benedict, crab cakes, and their delicious craft cocktails. They also have a kids menu, so if you have kids with you, this is a good spot!
11. Larsen’s Fish Market – Best for Seafood
Address: 56 Basin Rd, Chilmark, MA 02535, USA
Phone: +1 508-645-2680
The Larsen’s Fish Market is located in Menemsha and offers excellent seafood dishes. The restaurant serves fresh seafood which it sources directly from the local waters of Martha’s Vineyard. It also offers harbor views so that you enjoy your meal while dining at the restaurant. The best foods to try here include shrimp cocktail, smoked fish, lobster rolls, crab cakes, oysters, clam chowder, and lobster bisque. They also have a raw bar that offers oysters, cherrystones, and littlenecks.
12. Lookout Tavern – Best for Lobster Rolls
Address: 8 Seaview Ave, Oak Bluffs, MA 02557, USA
Phone: +1 508-696-9844
Lookout Tavern offers the best lobster rolls and fried clams in the town. The restaurant provides beautiful views of Oak Bluffs which you can enjoy with your favorite seafood from the raw bar or the cooked dishes. Their ingredients are locally sourced and fresh. Being here, you can enjoy fried seafood, chowder and bisque, burgers, appetizers, tacos, sandwiches, and salads.
13. 7a Foods – Best for Burgers and Sandwiches
Address: 1045 State Rd, West Tisbury, MA 02575, USA
Phone: +1 508-693-4636
7a Foods is best known for its huge juicy burgers and sandwiches. The restaurant sources ingredients from its own farm. They offer sandwiches, bagels, burgers, baked goods, wraps, and salads. 7a Foods has a lively and laid-back atmosphere, where people mostly visit to have breakfast-to-go options. Besides their go-to meal options, they have mains too which you can order to dine in. For example, you can order Asian pulled pork, tuna melt, curried lentil soup, and 7a Medianoche.
14. Chilmark Tavern – Best for Vegan Options
Address: 9 State Rd, Chilmark, MA 02535, USA
Phone: +1 508-645-9400
Chilmark Tavern is a small and cozy restaurant, perfect for hanging out with friends and family. Their best offers include fish and chips, toasted Italian sub, burrata, pasta, steak, poulet frites, and burgers. They also have vegan options which include organic tofu, soba noodles, and seared shiitake. The restaurant has some of the best martinis and best mixers for cocktails, but you can also bring your own bottle of wine along.
15. The Seafood Shanty – Best for Fresh Seafood
Address: 31 Dock St, Edgartown, MA 02539, USA
Phone: +1 508-627-8622
The Seafood Shanty is a popular hangout spot for the locals. The restaurant serves delicious seafood dishes and has a perfect casual setting with harbor views of Edgar town. The seafood is made from sea animals caught from local waters. From sushi, lobster rolls, and fried clams, you’ll find everything that you crave for seafood. You can order sides, sandwiches, appetizers, from the char-boiler, beverages, and ice cream.
Martha’s Vineyard is a Haven for Casual Dining
The laid-back and friendly atmosphere is perfect for casual restaurants on Martha’s Vineyard. Whether you’re in beach attire or more dressed up, you’ll feel comfortable at most eateries. The island’s natural beauty provides a stunning backdrop for your dining experience. Many casual dining spots offer outdoor seating with views of the ocean, harbors, or scenic landscapes, making your meal more enjoyable.
Also check out our favorite spots for Breakfast on the Vineyard or Waterfront Restaurants.