Fine Dining Restaurants on Nantucket

September 08, 2023

Eating at one of the best fine dining restaurants on Nantucket is a delightful experience, as the island offers a range of upscale dining establishments known for their exquisite cuisine and charming ambiance. Fine dining restaurants on Nantucket often have delightful settings, whether they are located in historic buildings or feature stunning ocean views. Take time to appreciate the unique flavors and culture of the island.

Our Pick of Fine Dining Restaurants on Nantucket

Toppers

Address: 120 Wauwinet Rd
City/State/ Zip Code: Nantucket, MA 02554

Once in TOPPER’S, you’re greeted by an ambience that’s both refined and relaxed. The restaurant has relaxing views of Nantucket’s shoreline, providing an awe-inspiring backdrop to an already exceptional meal. The interior exudes a timeless elegance, creating an atmosphere where you feel both welcomed and indulged.

TOPPER’s is renowned for its dedication to locally sourced ingredients, highlighting the island’s seasonal bounty in every dish. The menu is a testament to Nantucket’s maritime heritage, featuring an array of fresh seafood that is as tasty, tangy, and appetizing as it is beautifully presented. From buttery lobster bisque to perfectly seared scallops, each plate is a masterpiece that pays homage to the sea.

“To eat well, I always disagree with critics who say that all restaurants should be fine dining. You can get a Michelin star if you serve the best hamburger in the world.” –

David Chang

Cru

Address: 1 Straight Wharf
City/State/Zip Code: Nantucket, MA 02554

Cru, an enchanting dining haven nestled in the heart of fine dining on Nantucket, is known a symphony of coastal elegance and culinary mastery. This waterfront gem, situated along Straight Wharf, harmoniously marries stunning vistas of the harbor with an exquisite dining experience.

From the first step through its nautical-inspired entrance, Cru effortlessly transports guests to a world of refined maritime charm. The restaurant’s chic and airy atmosphere, complemented by tasteful marine décor, sets the tone for an exceptional journey of flavors.

Cru’s menu is a love letter to the sea, expertly curated to display the freshest catches and seasonal produce that Nantucket’s waters offer. Whether it’s the delicate briny notes of the freshly shucked oysters or the tantalizing richness of the butter-poached lobster, each dish is a testament to the ocean’s bounty and the culinary finesse of the chef.

“Fine dining is dying out everywhere… but I think there will be – and there has to always be – room for at least a small number of really fine, old-school fine-dining restaurants.”

– Anthony Bourdain

Brant Point Grill

Address: White Elephant, 50 Easton St
City/State/Zip Code: Nantucket, MA 02554

Brant Point Grill, ensconced in the heart of the idyllic Nantucket island, is a culinary haven that impeccably marries coastal charm with exceptional dining. From the moment you step into this culinary sanctuary, you’re transported into a realm of refined elegance and gastronomic delight.

Nantucket’s maritime history and island allure are beautifully encapsulated in Brant Point Grill’s ambience. It’s warm, nautical-themed decor and panoramic views of the harbor create an inviting and intimate atmosphere, making it equally suitable for both romantic evenings and gatherings with friends.

The menu at Brant Point Grill highlights an exquisite tapestry of local taste and world-class culinary artistry. The ocean’s bounty takes center stage, with a dazzling array of freshly caught seafood prepared with finesse and creativity. The signature raw bar is a treasure trove for seafood enthusiasts, offering an assortment of oysters, clams, and other delicacies that reflect the best of fine dining restaurants on  Nantucket.

The dimmed lights, exposed brick walls, and tasteful décor create an intimate atmosphere that’s perfect for a romantic evening….

Oran Mor

Address: 12 Federal St
City/State/Zip Code: Nantucket, MA 02554

Oran Mor, with its enchanting fusion of Scottish and coastal New England influences, is the next stop on our list. This restaurant effortlessly weaves together rustic charm and refined elegance, offering a dining experience that feels both cozy and sophisticated.

Upon stepping into Oran Mor, the warm ambience embraces you like an old friend. The dimmed lights, exposed brick walls, and tasteful décor create an intimate atmosphere that’s perfect for a romantic evening or a gathering of close friends. The essence of Nantucket’s coastal charm is subtly woven into every corner of the space.

Oran Mor’s menu showcases a tantalizing array of dishes that bridge the gap between Scottish traditions and the bounties of the local sea. The commitment to using fresh, seasonal ingredients shines through in every bite. From the delicate seafood platters that pay homage to Nantucket’s nautical heritage to the hearty Scottish-inspired comfort foods, each dish is a harmonious blend of flavors, textures, and cultural influences.

The Pearl

Address: 12 Federal St
City/State/Zip Code: Nantucket, MA 02554

Step into a world of culinary enchantment at The Pearl in Nantucket, where the art of Asian Fusion cuisine is masterfully woven into a symphony of flavors and experiences. This gem of a restaurant effortlessly marries the traditions of the East with the coastal charm of Nantucket, resulting in an exceptional dining adventure.

From the moment you step inside, The Pearl’s ambience transports you to a realm of sophistication and allure. The decor blends contemporary elegance with subtle Asian accents, creating an atmosphere that is both inviting and exotic.

The heart of The Pearl lies in its Asian Fusion cuisine, a harmonious dance of tastes that pays homage to the culinary treasures of multiple regions. Whether it’s the delicate balance of umami in a sashimi platter or the intricate layers of flavors in a Thai-inspired curry, each dish is a work of art that speaks to the restaurant’s commitment to culinary excellence.

Galley Beach

Address: 54 Jefferson Ave
City/State/Zip Code: Nantucket, MA 02554

Galley Beach in Nantucket stands as a quintessential embodiment of coastal luxury and culinary finesse. As you step onto the pristine shores of Nantucket Island and find yourself immersed in the soothing rhythm of the waves, Galley Beach invites you to an exquisite dining experience that marries the beauty of the ocean with culinary artistry.

The restaurant’s breathtaking setting right on the beachfront sets the stage for a memorable evening. The panoramic views of the Nantucket Sound paired with the golden hues of a sunset create an enchanting backdrop for an unparalleled dining journey.

Galley Beach’s menu is a symphony of flavors that celebrates both land and sea. With a focus on local, seasonal ingredients, every dish is a masterpiece that pays homage to the region’s rich maritime heritage. From the delicate briny oysters sourced from nearby waters to the tender, impeccably grilled seafood, each plate is a testament to the chef’s dedication to perfection.

The Boarding House

Address: 12 Federal St
City/State/Zip Code: Nantucket, MA 02554

The Boarding House in Nantucket stands as a captivating testament to the island’s culinary excellence. With its storied charm and innovative fare, this restaurant offers a dining experience that’s as memorable as the island itself.

As you step into The Boarding House, you’re immediately greeted by an ambience that’s equal parts sophistication and warmth. The cozy yet elegant interior, adorned with nautical touches, provides a perfect backdrop for the culinary journey that’s about to unfold.

The menu at The Boarding House is a culinary tapestry woven with the finest ingredients that Nantucket has to offer. From the first bite to the last, each dish is a harmonious blend of flavors, textures, and creativity. Whether you’re savoring the delicate richness of locally caught seafood or reveling in the harmonious fusion of farm-fresh produce, each plate is a masterpiece of culinary craftsmanship.

The Seagrille

Address: 45 Sparks Ave
City/State/Zip Code: Nantucket, MA 02554

The Seagrille in Nantucket is a hidden culinary gem that embodies the essence of the island’s charm and maritime heritage. This intimate eatery combines a warm, inviting atmosphere with a menu that showcases the bounty of both land and sea, creating a memorable experience that captures the heart of fine dining restaurants on Nantucket.

Upon entering The Seagrille, you’re welcomed by a cozy and rustic ambience that immediately transports you to the island’s relaxed and elegant spirit. The decor pays homage to Nantucket’s seafaring past, and the friendly staff exudes genuine hospitality.

The menu at The Seagrille is a true testament to the restaurant’s commitment to excellence. From the first bite, it’s clear that the culinary team takes pride in using locally sourced ingredients to craft dishes that are both flavorful and inventive. Fresh catches from the sea, such as succulent scallops and buttery lobster, are prepared with a deft hand that highlights their natural flavors.

Enjoying the Culinary Delights of Nantucket

Fine dining restaurants on Nantucket can be in high demand, especially during the peak summer season. To secure a table at your desired restaurant, make reservations well in advance, preferably a few weeks or even months ahead, especially if you have a specific date and time in mind.

Follow this link to explore Casual Dining on Nantucket or ideas for a Day Trip to Nantucket.