Collection of Best 8 Gift Shops in Nantucket

February 2024

If you are headed to island of Nantucket for a quick day trip, weekend getaway or to spend the heavenly summer months and need to know what the must-have clothing, festive decors, souvenirs, beach accessories or jewelry, this curated piece that showcases the 7 best gift shops on Nantucket will serve as your dedicated guide. Enjoy your stay!

Best Gift Shops on Nantucket

1. It’s A Shore Thing

Address: 30B Main Street | Nantucket, Ma 02554
City/Town: Nantucket

At It’s a Shore Thing Gift Shop in Downtown Nantucket, you’ll discover a collection of unique and memorable island gifts for everyone on your list. Conveniently located just minutes away from the Hy-Line Ferry Terminal, the store has an eclectic mix of merchandise that is both classic and contemporary, all with an unmistakable island-inspired flair. 

What sets us apart is our commitment to sourcing many of the items from local artisans and designers right here on Nantucket, ensuring that our offerings are truly one-of-a-kind. Whether you’re searching for island jewelry, specialty signs, or charming message stones, It’s a Shore Thing Gift Shop is your go-to destination for finding the perfect gift that captures the essence of Nantucket.

2. Four Winds Gifts

Address: 8 Straight Wharf | Nantucket, Ma 02554
City/Town: Nantucket

For over half a century, Four Winds Gifts has been a cherished fixture in the heart of Nantucket. As the oldest gift shop on the island located in the famous Blacksmith building, this family-owned business is deeply rooted in the island’s rich history and traditions. With a curated selection of authentic Nantucket products, visitors and locals can enjoy an opportunity to take home a piece of the island’s timeless charm.

Four Winds is chock full of must-haves, celebratory items, clothing, home goods, and unique gifts that capture the essence of Nantucket living. From cozy sweaters perfect for breezy beach days to festive decor for a Nantucket Christmas, the collection reflects the island’s distinct character and enduring allure.

3. The Hub of Nantucket

Address: 31 Main Street | Nantucket, Ma 02554
City/Town: Nantucket

Located on Main Street in the heart of Nantucket, The Hub represents island tradition and community gathering. Known as the go-to spot for locals, it has become synonymous with Nantucket’s exciting spirit.

The Hub has a wonderful ambience enabling patrons to unwind with a cup of coffee and peruse the day’s headlines on the benches outside.  Since 2013, The Hub has expanded its offerings to include a full coffee and beverage bar, serving up delicious lattes, teas, smoothies, bagels, and more, further cementing its status as a beloved community hub where memories are made, and traditions are upheld.

4. Toujours Midi Nantucket- formerly Le Cherc Midi

Address: 30 Main Street Unit C | Nantucket, Ma 02554
City/Town: Nantucket

Toujours Midi Nantucket, formerly known as Le Cherche Midi, has been a fixture on Nantucket since 1990. Originally inspired by the quaint streets of Paris, Laurie Herrmann took over the shop in 2008 and rebranded it as Toujours Midi, meaning “always noon.” While the name may seem enigmatic, it symbolizes the shop’s enduring presence and commitment to its French heritage blended seamlessly with Nantucket’s unique charm.

From hand-crafted treasures to timeless accessories, the shop caters to a diverse array of tastes and occasions. Visitors often find themselves enchanted by the shop’s eclectic offerings, exclaiming that it’s the best-kept secret on the island. 

5. Island Variety

Address: 59 Old South Rd | Nantucket, Ma 02554
City/Town: Nantucket

Island Variety, established in January 2000, has been a beloved fixture of the community for over two decades.  At Island Variety, customers can expect a diverse array of merchandise catering to various tastes and preferences.

From locally crafted souvenirs and artisanal gifts to everyday essentials and specialty items, the shop offers something for everyone.  Island Variety remains a cherished part of the community, thanks to the dedication of its founders and the ongoing support of loyal patrons.

6. Stephanie’s

Address: 42 Main Street | Nantucket, Ma 02554
City/Town: Nantucket

Stephanie’s has been on Nantucket’s Main Street since 1997. This gift store welcomes all with its unique collection and allure. It prides itself as Nantucket’s most affordable boutique by curating a delightful selection of items catering to the dynamic tastes of the modern woman. 

The boutique’s shelves boast an array of treasures, from whimsical home accents that add flair to any space to stylish apparel that exudes coastal charm. With its commitment to affordability and quality, Stephanie’s has become a beloved destination for locals and visitors alike, offering a glimpse into the unique charm of Nantucket living.

7. Andersons

Address: 29 Main Street | Nantucket, Ma 02554
City/Town: Nantucket

Andersons is the place to go on Nantucket for those that want the island’s finest home decor. Their boutique offers an array of sophisticated home furnishings, lighting, and tabletop items, all curated with a sea side chic style specific to Nantucket. 

What sets Andersons apart is their focus on quality and uniqueness, with many pieces being custom-made and exclusively available either online or at their Main Street location. Regardless of your reason or tastes, Andersons provides a curated collection of items that capture the essence of Nantucket’s laid-back luxury.

8. Sunken Ship

Address: 12 Broad Street | Nantucket, Ma 02554
City/Town: Nantucket

Established in 1975 by Philip Osley, The Sunken Ship started as a modest dive shop offering sporting goods, fishing poles, and scuba gear. Over the years, the shop has evolved into a treasure trove of eclectic finds, reflecting its founder’s commitment to meeting customers’ diverse needs. From hats and caps to children’s gear, stickers, and flags, The Sunken Ship offers an array of items to suit every taste and preference.

In addition to its wide selection of merchandise, The Sunken Ship prides itself on providing a welcoming atmosphere and personalized service. Whether you’re a local resident or a visitor exploring the area, a visit to The Sunken Ship promises a delightful shopping experience filled with unique finds and friendly faces.

Taking Home an Island Memory

Whether you are summering on the island or spending a short holiday here, your stay will not be complete without taking a leisurely afternoon to browse these fabulous gift shops on Nantucket and find some treasures to take home with you.

Also check out our Gift Shops on Cape Cod.