10 Best Bed-Breakfast and Inns Lodging on Martha's Vineyard
October 06, 2023
Discover the charm and comfort of island life through the delightful bed & breakfasts and inns on Martha’s Vineyard. Nestled in this island paradise are hidden gems waiting to make your stay unforgettable. From the cozy elegance of The Look Inn to the seaside allure of Beachfront Inn, this article guides you through some of the finest lodging options, ensuring your Martha’s Vineyard getaway is as inviting as it is memorable.
Our Pick for the Best B&Bs and Inns on Martha’s Vineyard
1. The Broad Meadow Bed & Breakfast
Address: 74 Elias Ln, West Tisbury, MA 02575
Phone: +1 508-693-3584
The Broad Meadow Bed & Breakfast is a hidden gem nestled on the picturesque Martha’s Vineyard. Having undergone a complete renovation thirteen summers ago, this centrally located haven offers an unforgettable island experience. Guests are treated to more than just comfortable accommodations; they receive a parking pass to Lambert’s Cove Beach, one of the world’s prettiest, and access to The Trustees of Reservations Long Point Wildlife Refuge, a serene stretch of beach and pond over the dunes.
For those with active inclinations, the nearby West Tisbury Town Tennis Courts and the island’s extensive bike paths provide ample opportunities for recreation. The peaceful Broad Meadow grounds, complete with a hammock and meadow views, offer a serene respite. With easy access to walking trails and a short distance from up-island wedding venues, this B&B provides a perfect island escape.
2. The Oak Bluffs Inn
Address: 64 Circuit Ave, Oak Bluffs, MA 02557
Phone: +1 508-693-7171
The Oak Bluffs Inn, a timeless Martha’s Vineyard gem, showcases a rich history that dates back to 1870. Once a private residence, this Victorian beauty transformed into a welcoming Inn under the visionary ownership of Will Elliott, Holley, and later, Rhonda and Erik Albert.
Architect Mark Hutker’s inspired lighthouse design now graces its exterior, making it an iconic landmark. While staying here, you will bask in classic Victorian elegance combined with a touch of modern coastal charm.
Throughout its storied past, The Oak Bluffs Inn has hosted an array of illustrious guests, from Spike Lee to jazz virtuoso Wynton Marsalis. However, it is not just the famous who are captivated by its allure; visitors seeking a taste of history and a glimpse of the Vineyard’s charm find solace within its walls.
You should note that due to the inn’s historic construction, it does not offer ADA accessible rooms, and accessibility features like ramps and elevators are absent. However, the inn’s rich heritage and the island’s beauty more than make up for any limitations in its layout.
3. Nobnocket Boutique Inn
Address: 60 Mount Aldworth Rd, Vineyard Haven, MA 02568
Phone: +1 508-696-0859
Nobnocket Boutique Inn in Martha’s Vineyard is a true gem for discerning travelers. Its contemporary interior design, featuring renowned pieces from designers like Marcel Wanders and Philippe Starck, sets the stage for a luxurious and unique stay. Bathrooms adorned with glass, tile, and marble provide a modern, opulent touch. High-speed WiFi and Bluetooth music devices cater to tech-savvy guests.
The inn’s spacious common rooms and cozy seating areas offer a perfect retreat after a day exploring the island. Whether you are relaxing by the grand fireplace or enjoying the sunshine in the bright sunroom, comfort and elegance surround you. Outdoors, the inn boasts 1.8 acres of gardens, home to various bird species and a local wild turkey troupe. With multiple patios and verandas, there’s ample space to savor the fresh Martha’s Vineyard air. Nobnocket Boutique Inn elevates island living to a whole new level, promising an unforgettable experience.
4. The Dockside Inn
Address: 9 Circuit Ave Extension, Oak Bluffs, 02557, MA
Phone: 1 (508) 273-8596
The Dockside Inn in Martha’s Vineyard is a charming boutique-style hotel nestled along the picturesque Oak Bluffs Harbor. Under the ownership of local proprietors since 2012, this inn has undergone extensive renovations, resulting in a fusion of modern amenities and whimsical nautical decor.
The inn offers 22 tastefully decorated rooms, many with stunning views of Oak Bluffs Harbor. Its expansive porches provide the perfect spots for basking in the sunshine, witnessing breathtaking sunsets, or indulging in some people-watching. The friendly and knowledgeable staff are always ready to assist with tour arrangements, transportation, or any inquiries about Martha’s Vineyard. Complimentary ice cream treats and fresh baked cookies add a warm touch to your stay.
The Dockside Inn’s harbor-side location makes it an ideal base for exploring Martha’s Vineyard, with shopping, dining, beaches, and numerous attractions just steps away.
5. Crocker Inn
Address: 12 Crocker Ave, Vineyard Haven, MA 02568
Phone: +1 508-693-1151
The Crocker House Inn on Martha’s Vineyard is a haven of luxury and tranquility. Innkeepers Jynell and Jeff Kristal, with their extensive Marriott background, have crafted a retreat that exudes comfort and pampering. Whether you are visiting for a wedding, a family gathering, a honeymoon, or a romantic escape, The Crocker House Inn offers an ideal setting for all occasions.
The inn’s front porch invites you to unwind in rocking chairs, taking in the serene atmosphere that envelops this charming establishment. From the warm hospitality to the serene ambiance, The Crocker House Inn promises an unforgettable experience, making it the perfect place to stay on Martha’s Vineyard for those seeking both relaxation and indulgence.
6. Ashley Inn
Address: 129 Main Street, Edgartown, MA 02539
Phone: +1 508-627-9655
The Ashley Inn on Martha’s Vineyard is a charming 19th-century sea captain’s home, steeped in history and island charm. Originally built in 1860 by Captain William H. Crowell upon retiring from the island’s whaling industry, this large house has captured the admiration of visitors and locals alike for over a century. Its unique cloverleaf window and distinctive accents add character to the inn.
In the late 19th century, Captain Crowell’s daughter Mary and her husband, Captain George W. Brown, took over the estate. Captain Brown, a renowned sea captain, sailed the world’s seas, bringing back exotic treasures. This rich history continued through the generations, with the house eventually becoming a small, gracious inn in 1983.
As one of the oldest inns on Martha’s Vineyard, The Ashley Inn welcomes guests to experience the legacy of Martha’s Vineyard in a warm and inviting atmosphere, marking its 30th anniversary of hospitality.
7. Tivoli Inn
Address: 129 Circuit Ave, Oak Bluffs, MA 02667
Phone: +1 508-693-7928
The Tivoli Inn on Martha’s Vineyard is a delightful Victorian gingerbread house that transports you to a bygone era while offering modern comforts. Built in the late 1800s, the inn has been meticulously restored to its former glory. Its charm is immediately evident with a flowery balcony and wrap-around latticed porch perfect for relaxation.
Inside, you will find six cheerfully decorated rooms that combine style with comfort. The inn’s commitment to affordability means that rates are reasonable and vary based on your needs. Established in 1988 by two sisters, the Tivoli Inn has become a beloved destination for guests seeking local charm and hospitality. Whether you are a first-time visitor or a returning guest, the Tivoli Inn promises an unforgettable island experience. Come stay with them and discover the best of Martha’s Vineyard!
8. Beachfront Inn
Address: 65 Seaview Ave, Oak Bluff, MA 02557
Phone: +1 508-693-5148
The Beachfront Inn on Martha’s Vineyard is a charming escape that seamlessly blends history and modern comfort. This beachfront gem, housed within the 1873 Tillinghast Cottage, is steeped in rich heritage. The cottage, designed by renowned Victorian architect Samuel Freeman Pratt, boasts Pratt’s distinctive “Bird Cage” style, reminiscent of Newport’s grand mansions.
Owned by the Arend family since 1959 and welcoming guests since 1982, the inn offers a unique glimpse into the island’s history. Under new ownership in 2018, the property now combines its storied past with contemporary updates while preserving its original character.
The Beachfront Inn invites you to savor one of the historic inns of Martha’s Vineyard, where coastal elegance meets timeless allure.
9. The Lightkeepers Inn
Address: 25 Simpsons Ln, Edgartown, MA 02539
Phone: +1 508-627-4600
The Lightkeeper’s Inn in Edgartown, Martha’s Vineyard, exudes timeless charm and historical significance. Nestled in the heart of Edgartown, this classic all-suites inn offers a perfect blend of convenience and tranquility. Guests find themselves just a short walk away from the island’s finest restaurants, shops, and picturesque beaches.
Each suite at The Lightkeeper’s Inn provides a comfortable haven, complete with a full kitchen, living room, bedroom, bath, and a private entrance—a true home away from home. Complimentary parking, a rare find on the island, adds to the convenience.
Steeped in history, the inn once served as the residence of Henry Thomas Lyman, the lightkeeper of The Edgartown Lighthouse from 1931 to 1938. The connection to the island’s maritime past is further enriched by the nearby Cape Poge Lighthouse. Here, you will experience the perfect harmony of past and present, ensuring an unforgettable Martha’s Vineyard getaway.
10. The Look Inn
Address: 25 Look St, Vineyard Haven, MA 02568
Phone: +1 508-693-6893
The Look Inn on Martha’s Vineyard offers a delightful escape to the island’s simpler days. This charmingly restored 1806 farmhouse, conveniently located near Main Street in Vineyard Haven, ensures easy access to the ferry, shopping, dining, and beaches. The inn exudes a casual simplicity that feels like visiting a dear friend’s home. Each of the three rooms is tastefully furnished with a queen-size bed and a private sink while sharing a full bath.
What truly sets The Look Inn apart is the warm hospitality of innkeepers Freddy and Catherine. They provide not just comfortable accommodations but also insider knowledge on the island’s best spots, be it gourmet restaurants or hidden beaches. The daily hearty continental breakfast served on the sunporch offers a beautiful view to start your day. The Look Inn embodies the magic of Martha’s Vineyard in all seasons, making it a cherished getaway for returning guests. Experience the island’s allure firsthand and relish the warmth of The Look Inn’s welcome.
As you explore the rich offerings of the island, consider the inviting embrace of its bed & breakfasts or historic inns on Martha’s Vineyard. From the Victorian allure of The Oak Bluffs Inn to the intimate luxury of Nobnocket Boutique Inn, these lodgings provide an authentic taste of island life.
Experience genuine hospitality, stunning vistas, and the serenity of this idyllic destination while indulging in the comforts of these charming accommodations. Your visit to Martha’s Vineyard promises to be an experience to cherish for years to come.