6 Exceptional Local Jewelers on Nantucket

Nantucket, an extraordinary island known for its natural beauty and rich maritime heritage, is also home to a vibrant community of local jewelers who craft exquisite pieces inspired by the island’s charm. These jewelers on Nantucket have garnered acclaim for their exceptional craftsmanship, unique designs, and unwavering commitment to providing fine jewelry.

Their creations, found in the jewelry stores on Nantucket, reflect the island’s timeless allure and are cherished by residents and visitors alike. In this article, we present the best six local jewelers on Nantucket, each with a distinct style and a passion for capturing the spirit of this enchanting island.

Our Pick of the Best Jewelers on Nantucket

1. Jewel in the Sea

Address: 6 Straight Wharf | Nantucket, Ma 02554
City/Town: Nantucket

Jewel In The Sea is a cherished family-owned and operated local jeweler on Nantucket, known for its unwavering commitment to exceptional customer service and building enduring relationships. Established on the island in 2016 by Meg and Jack, Jewel In The Sea has become an integral part of the Nantucket community.  Their devotion to Nantucket is mirrored in the quality of their jewelry services.

Open year-round, Jewel In The Sea specializes in crafting custom diamond jewelry and stands as a trusted choice among Nantucket locals for jewelry and watch repairs, appraisals, engraving, ear piercing, and more. Their diverse collection includes handmade nautical and Nantucket-inspired jewelry, alongside fine jewelry pieces and watches, ensuring there’s something for every jewelry enthusiast. Whether you visit their store or explore their offerings online, Jewel In The Sea’s commitment to quality and community shines through.

2. Susan Lister Locke Jeweler

Address: 28 Easy St | Nantucket, Ma 02554
City/Town: Nantucket

Susan Lister Locke is one of the most prominent jewelers on Nantucket. Her artistic journey began with a deep-rooted passion for fashion design and drawing, ultimately guiding her towards the world of art and jewelry.

With a background in metal-smithing, Susan’s work reflects her fascination with nature and her love for Art Deco and iconic artists. She skillfully combines 18 karat gold, metals, and vibrant gemstones to craft unique, timeless, and beautiful jewelry pieces. Renowned as the Best Jeweler on Nantucket from 2017 to 2023, her artistry is showcased at The Susan Lister Locke Gallery on Nantucket, Palm Beach, FL, and various exclusive venues across the United States.

3. The Jewelers’ Gallery

Address: 21 Center St | Nantucket 02554
City/Town: Nantucket

The Jewelers’ Gallery is Nantucket’s most longstanding jewelry store, boasting a rich history of providing exquisite jewelry to the island’s residents and visitors. With a focus on showcasing the exceptional work of both local artisans and nationally renowned goldsmiths, The Jewelers’ Gallery offers a collection that embodies the timeless beauty of Nantucket.

They prioritize fine handcrafted jewelry that remains elegant and ageless, mirroring the enduring allure of Nantucket’s shores and natural beauty. This commitment to timeless designs and high-quality craftsmanship has made The Jewelers Gallery a trusted and beloved destination for those seeking exquisite jewelry on the island.

4. Jessica Hicks

Address: 2 Union St | Nantucket, Ma 02554
City/Town: Nantucket

Jessica Hicks one of the highly regarded local jewelers on Nantucket, is known for her exceptional craftsmanship and unique designs. Her jewelry pieces reflect the island’s natural beauty and maritime heritage. With over a decade of experience, Jessica skillfully combines precious metals and gemstones to create exquisite, one-of-a-kind pieces that capture the essence of Nantucket.

Her work often incorporates nautical elements and ocean-inspired motifs, appealing to both residents and visitors. Jessica Hicks’ dedication to her craft and her commitment to showcasing Nantucket’s charm through her jewelry make her one of the top local jewelers on the island, offering distinctive pieces that evoke the spirit of Nantucket.

5. R Simantov Fine Jewelry

Address: 1 Old North Wharf | Nantucket, Ma 02554
City/Town: Nantucket

R. Simantov Fine Jewelry is a renowned local jeweler on Nantucket, celebrated for its contemporary jewelry masterpieces of enduring value. The firm is known for reviving lost techniques from the past, showcasing exceptional craftsmanship and employing exquisite materials.

Their one-of-a-kind creations, with their whimsical beauty achieved through unique combinations of metals and precious stones, have garnered international design awards and found their place in permanent museum collections. These masterpieces are reminiscent of classical styles while incorporating modern elegance, making R. Simantov a top choice for those seeking unique and artistically inspired jewelers on Nantucket.

6. Barbara Harris Water Jewels

Address: 46 Main St | Nantucket, Ma 02554
City/Town: Nantucket

Barbara Harris Water Jewels is distinguished among the local jewelers on Nantucket, with a rich family heritage in the jewelry industry. Hailing from a lineage of jewelers established in London in the 1860s, Barbara’s passion for rare and semi-precious gems has been nurtured since her early childhood.

Inspired by nature, captivated by aquatic themes, and intrigued by architectural intricacies, Barbara’s artistic style is deeply rooted in her experiences and influences.   Barbara Harris Water Jewels stands as a testament to her passion, expertise, and unwavering dedication to the art of jewelry-making, making her one of the top local jewelers on Nantucket and beyond.

Top Jewelry Shops on Nantucket are a Destination

Nantucket’s top local jewelers are more than artisans; they are storytellers, crafting pieces that embody the island’s beauty, heritage, and maritime grace. From their dedication to community and custom timeless creations influenced by nature; these jewelers on Nantucket offer a rich tapestry of choices for those seeking exceptional jewelry on the island.

These local jewelry shops on Nantucket are an integral part of island’s artistic community, offering distinctive pieces that resonate with the island’s spirit and natural beauty. Nantucket has become a beloved destination for those seeking exquisite jewelry creations.

Discover More Jewelers on Cape Cod